If you didn’t hear about PBN PREMIUM, find out here: PBN PREMIUM

The Brandon Marsh trade was one of three moves the Phillies made at the 2022 deadline. Four years later it still looks like a fair swap that neither side can fully celebrate. On August 2, 2022, Philadelphia sent top catching prospect Logan O’Hoppe to the Angels for the young outfielder. Marsh is now coming off wrist surgery and is reportedly available in trade talks this winter. That makes this a good time to look at how the deal has aged and what the Phillies might look like without it.

The Deal and the Deadline Backdrop

The Phillies were chasing their first postseason berth since 2011 and had an obvious hole in center field. They were also one of the weaker defensive teams in baseball. On the same day, they added Noah Syndergaard from the Angels for Mickey Moniak and Jadiel Sanchez, and David Robertson from the Cubs for pitching prospect Ben Brown. They also designated Odubel Herrera for assignment.

Marsh was 24, a second round pick of the Angels in 2016 and a former top 50 prospect, but his bat had stalled. He was hitting .226/.284/.353 with eight homers in 93 games. The Phillies were buying his glove and his athleticism. Statcast had his nine Outs Above Average tied for second among qualifying outfielders, and his sprint speed ranked in the 91st percentile. He also came with club control through 2027.

O’Hoppe was a legitimate prize. A 23rd round pick in 2018, he had climbed to number three in the Phillies’ system and number 86 in baseball. He was hitting .275/.392/.496 with 15 homers in 75 games for Double-A Reading. The catch, from Philadelphia’s point of view, was that J.T. Realmuto was already signed long term, which made O’Hoppe a surplus chip.

Subscribe to keep reading

Become a paid subscriber to get access to the rest of this post and other exclusive content.