The looming end of the CBA makes today’s deadline to protect players from the Rule 5 Draft complicated, interesting, and perhaps, unnecessary. Complicated in that if a player is added to the 40-man roster and protected from the Rule 5 Draft, he then would be ineligible to play in the minors if there is a work stoppage. For a young player, that could be a big issue. Interesting because there are always decisions made that are puzzling to fans because a particular player was or was not protected and they expected the opposite. Unnecessary? With the lockout of 2021-2022, the Rule 5 Draft was never held. Of course in 1994-95, there was a Rule 5 Draft even though a work stoppage was in place.

Perhaps the owners have decided and quietly passed along to their team’s personnel whether or not the draft will be held; it’s one of those things we don’t know. Regardless, people like Dave Dombrowski have to make decisions based on what they know of the situation.

First, Aidan Miller is not eligible for the Rule 5 Draft. That’s great news for the Phillies and fans of minor league baseball because it means that Miller is safe, does not need to be placed on the 40-man roster, and will play in the minors if there is a work stoppage at the major league level.

First, a rules refresher

Any minor leaguer not on the 40-man roster and signed at age 18 or younger becomes eligible for the Rule 5 Draft after five full minor league seasons. Those signed at age 19 or older become eligible after four full minor league seasons. For the 2026 Rule 5 Draft, that means players who signed in 2023 or earlier and were 19 or older at the time they signed or players who signed in 2022 or earlier and were 18 or younger when they signed, are now eligible for the Rule 5 Draft and would need to be protected.

Players who are selected in the Major League phase of the Rule 5 Draft must be kept on the selecting team’s active MLB roster for an entire season, or otherwise be offered back to the original club. In the minor league phase, rules are more flexible, and players are relocated to affiliates without stringent roster use requirements.

Top Phillies Prospects Eligible for the Rule 5 Draft

Of players on MLB Pipeline’s list of the Phillies Top 30 prospects, five must be protected by the 6:00 p.m. deadline tonight or they will be eligible for the Rule 5 Draft. Those five are Bryan Rincon (4), Aroon Escobar (6), Juan Villavicencio (19), Wen-Hui Pan (20), and Mavis Graves (26).

There are other players like Raylin Heredia and Keaton Anthony, who are not on the top 30 list but are going to present the Phillies with some interesting decisions.

The Phillies have just two open spots on their 40-man roster, meaning that if they want to add more than two players they are going to have to start ditching players who are already on the 40-man. Players like Andrew Hoffman, Grant Holman, Max Lazar, Kameron Misner, Alan Rangel, and Colby Thomas could be designated for assignment to clear more spots. The Phillies also recently claimed a pair of infielders – Brett Harris and Shay Whitcomb – who are on the 40-man roster and could be designated for assignment.

Decisions on Phillies to Protect – Our Predictions

Bryan Rincon is a definite protection choice. The shortstop prospect fell just shy of the 30/30 minor league club with Double-A Reading with 26 home runs and 30 stolen bases this past season. He was the organization’s Paul Owens Award winner and posted a .927 OPS with Reading.

For various reasons, Rincon is the only real lock to be protected. He not only has great stats but played at Double-A, so teams could make a case for stashing him on their major league roster for a season in hopes he can be more than a bench rider down the road.

Second baseman Aroon Escobar and left-handed reliever Mavis Graves are interesting cases. Escobar had a somewhat down season after putting up big numbers in 2025. The Phillies have to decide if he is a guy who at 21 years of age was just overwhelmed at Double-A and is worth protecting or were his 2026 stats a sign of things to come. Also weighing on the situation is whether a team would take a shot at taking him in the draft knowing that he is going to likely struggle in the majors and losing a year of development could hurt long-term.

Graves struggled as a starter, but when he was moved into a relief role at Reading during the 2026 season things turned around quickly. In 37 starts with Jersey Shore over the 2025 and 2026 seasons, Graves had a 7-14 record with a 4.56 ERA. A mid-season promotion to Reading that was combined with a move to the bullpen resulted in 14 relief appearances with a 0.96 ERA.

Neither Escobar or Graves are major league ready, but Graves, who turns 23 later this week, is the type of player that teams look to stash in their bullpen. Let’s see, could the Phillies use a near major league ready left-handed reliever? It’s also tough to not protect a 21-year-old prospect who has a strong upside. It says here that both wind up being protected.

Wen-Hui Pan, 24, is another interesting decision. He had Tommy John surgery in 2024 and missed all of 2025, but bounced back nicely in 2026. With Clearwater, Jersey Shore, and Reading, Pan went 5-0 with six saves in six save opportunities, posting a combined 3.10 ERA in 38 relief outings. Like Graves, Pan has the profile that teams look to grab in the Rule 5 Draft. Look for the Phillies to protect him and add him to the 40-man roster.

Infielder Juan Villavicencio, who turns 23 next week, is the type of player that teams tend not to take in the Rule 5 Draft. His highest level in the minors is High-A Jersey Shore and he played just 33 games there in 2026. He is a definite prospect but it would be difficult for a team to put him on their active roster for an entire season. Odds are that he goes unprotected and also goes undrafted.

If the Phillies don’t protect Anthony, odds are that he gets pilfered by another team. He has played 111 games at Triple-A with a line of 13-60-.292/.366/.450. The problem is that with the Phillies he is blocked by Bryce Harper at first base and Kyle Schwarber as a DH. Those are the only two roles he has played in the minors. The Phillies also have another first baseman, Felix Reyes, on the 40-man roster. Reyes is tearing up the Dominican Winter League and is a former Eastern League MVP. The Phillies aren’t likely to protect him and he winds up elsewhere next season.

Raylin Heredia is a bubble-guy for sure. The 23-year-old had a breakout season in 2026 when he hit 23 home runs and stole 25 bases for Double-A Reading. He also drove in 74 runs and slashed .278/.317/.473 in his first season at Double-A. Defensively, he is a solid corner outfielder with a cannon for an arm and piled up 11 outfield assists in 2026. It would be hard not to protect a young right-handed hitting power outfielder, so look for him to be added to the 40-man roster.

Opening roster spots

That makes five players for the Phillies to protect. They have two open roster spots and are likely to add players as the offseason goes on. Look for Hoffman, Lazar, Misner, Thomas and one of Harris or Whitcomb to be DFA’d. Of course, a trade is also a possibility. Is it time to move Orion Kerkering and/or Jhoan Rojas?


Please scroll down to comment!

We appreciate your feedback!

Banner for Philly Baseball News featuring logo, slogan, and skyline of Philadelphia with social media icons.

Disclaimer: Some of the products featured or linked on this website may generate income for Philly Baseball News through affiliate commissions, sponsorships, or direct sales. We only promote items we believe in, but please assume that PBN may earn a cut from qualifying purchases that you make using a link on this site.

Privacy Policy | Contact us

© 2026 LV Sports Media. All rights reserved.