The Main Event

  • May 20, 1954 – Team President Bob Carpenter apologized to Granny Hamner for having him followed by a private detective. Hamner noticed a car following him home a day earlier. He called police, who found the other driver with two guns. When it became clear that the driver was hired by the Phillies, Hamner angrily demanded a trade. He dropped the demand after the apology, even though Carpenter would continue to use detectives to spot-check compliance with the team’s curfew.

On the morning of May 19, 1954, Philadelphia Phillies second baseman Granny Hamner made his way home from Connie Mack Stadium after a 6-2 loss to the Milwaukee Braves. Hamner was driving his two-tone Cadillac when the car trailing behind him seemed suspicious. He figured it had followed him all the way from the stadium to his home in the Mayfair neighborhood, and after watching the vehicle circle his block several times, he called the police. Around 1 a.m., the driver was arrested.

A Spy With Two Guns

The private detective, based out of Wilmington, Delaware, was held on $500 bail for a weapons charge after two pistols were found in the car. He was not carrying a permit to carry in Pennsylvania. The private detective initially lied to police, claiming his assignment was to trail an Air Force airman in a divorce case and that Hamner’s car resembled the airman’s. The cover story didn’t hold.

Phillies president Robert R.M. Carpenter came clean, announcing in a team statement that it was no case of mistaken identity — he had employed a detective agency to check on some of his players. The gumshoes were tasked with ensuring compliance with the team’s postgame curfew: midnight after day games and 2 a.m. after night games.

Hamner, never known to hold back, denounced the tactics as “Gestapo-like.” He demanded a trade. Carpenter called him the following morning and offered a public apology, calling Hamner one of his favorite players and saying he could not blame him for being angry. Hamner, who was hitting .365 at the time with the Phillies a game out of first place, eventually dropped the trade demand — though he noted the particular irony pointed out by Carpenter himself: Gran had, in fact, been home in good time.

Carpenter’s Broader Surveillance Operation

The 1954 incident was not an isolated event. Carpenter had grown increasingly convinced — a theory that first emerged as early as 1951 — that the team’s middling results after the 1950 pennant were due to the players’ off-field activities, and he hired private detectives to tail them accordingly. According to the Philadelphia Inquirer, Carpenter had been running surveillance on players as early as 1946, and when checks revealed a player acting out, the matter was addressed privately. “Usually one talk was enough,” Carpenter said. He also defended the practice publicly, claiming that most major league clubs followed the same policy.

Who Was Bob Carpenter?

Robert Ruliph Morgan Carpenter Jr. was born in 1915 in Montchanin, a community in New Castle County, Delaware. His mother was an heir to the DuPont Company fortune, and the family purchased the Phillies in 1943 for $400,000. He was just 28 years old at the time, making him the youngest club president in National League history.

He took an active role in managing the franchise and worked to give the club the dignity and respectability it had long lacked. He never took a salary, and he never expected to show large profits. “If anybody goes into this business for money,” he once said, “he should have his head examined.” His fingerprints were on some of the franchise’s best decisions — during his 28 years as president, his teams signed future Hall of Famers Robin Roberts, Richie Ashburn, and Mike Schmidt.

Yet Carpenter was also paternalistic in his management style. His belief that player behavior off the field was the primary obstacle to winning caused genuine friction. The relationship with Hamner in particular slipped from volatile to something resembling a soap opera following the detective incident. Hamner would again publicly criticize management three months later, throwing barbs at interim manager Terry Moore, a move that crossed a line even with his own teammates.

A Wider Pattern in Baseball

Carpenter’s defense — that other clubs did the same — was not entirely without merit. The use of private detectives to monitor players was not unheard of in 1950s baseball, an era when owners exercised enormous control over players with little formal recourse available through any union. Players had no free agency, minimal leverage, and contracts that bound them indefinitely through the reserve clause. In that context, surveillance was one more tool of control, just rarely one that ended with a detective getting arrested while armed at 1 a.m. in a Philadelphia neighborhood.

The weapons charge against the detective was later dismissed. Carpenter continued using private detectives for curfew checks after the apology. The Hamner incident remains one of the more remarkable and under-told stories of the Phillies’ postwar era — a moment when a fiery infielder, a suspicious Cadillac, and an armed gumshoe briefly made Philadelphia’s front office the most scrutinized operation in baseball.

Philadelphia Baseball Events for May 20

  • May 20, 1951 – Richie Ashburn collects eight hits in a doubleheader, the last Phillie to do so. He was 4-5 in the opener and 4-6 in the nightcap with all eight hits being singles.
  • May 20, 1958 – Released Roy Smalley. Smalley is the father of Roy Smalley, who played for the Minnesota Twins. He is also the brother-in-law of Gene Mauch. This Roy Smalley played for the Phillies from 1955-1958 and hit .204 with the team.
  • May 20, 1962 – In a doubleheader, Chicago Cubs rookie Ken Hubbs hits eight singles in eight at bats as the Cubs sweep the Philadelphia Phillies, 6-4 and 11-2.
  • May 20, 1883 – Steve Carlton fans four Padres, moving past Walter Johnson to second on the all-time strikeout list with 3,511. Nolan Ryan had taken over first place earlier in the season. The Phils lost the game to San Diego, 5-0.
  • May 20, 1988 – Mike Schmidt hits his 535th career home run, moving him to eighth on the all-time home run list, passing Jimmie Foxx.
  • May 20, 2001 – The Phillies conduct their first bobble-head giveaway — a Pat Burrell model.
  • May 20, 2006 – Brett Myers gives up a solo home run to Boston pitcher Josh Beckett — the first home run by a Red Sox pitcher since the start of the DH era in 1973. Beckett had the opportunity to hit because the DH rule was not used when teams played in a National League park.
  • May 20, 2023 – Claimed Dylan Covey of waivers from the L.A. Dodgers. Covey made one start and 27 relief appearances with the Phillies in 2023 with a 3.69 ERA. That season would be his last in the majors.

Philadelphia Baseball for May 20

  • Stan Benjamin (born 1914) – Started his MLB career with the Phillies in 1939 and was with the team through 1942. In his 227 games with the Phillies, Benjamin played every position except shortstop, catcher, and pitcher.
  • Wilson Valdez (born 1978) – An infielder, Valdez hit .254 with the 2010-2011 Phillies, playing in 210 games.
  • Jayson Werth (born 1979) – Signed with the Phillies as a free agent in December of 2006 and played in Philly through the 2010 season. He then signed with Washington and spent the rest of his career with the Nationals. He hit 95-300-.282 with the Phillies and 229-799-.267 over a 15-year career.

Please scroll down to comment!

We appreciate your feedback!

Banner for Philly Baseball News featuring logo, slogan, and skyline of Philadelphia with social media icons.

Disclaimer: Some of the products featured or linked on this website may generate income for Philly Baseball News through affiliate commissions, sponsorships, or direct sales. We only promote items we believe in, but please assume that PBN may earn a cut from qualifying purchases that you make using a link on this site.

Privacy Policy | Contact us

© 2026 LV Sports Media. All rights reserved.