A look at the biggest events and birthdays from April 20 in Phillies history.

The Main Event

April 20, 1985 – Traded Al Holland and Frankie Griffin to Pittsburgh Pirates in exchange for Kent Tekulve.

When the Philadelphia Phillies and Pittsburgh Pirates swapped Al Holland and Frankie Griffin for Kent Tekulve, it was a deal that looked modest on paper but carried real stylistic implications for both bullpens. To understand whether it worked, you have to look at what Holland had been in Philadelphia and what Tekulve became once he arrived.

Al Holland in Philadelphia

Holland’s Phillies tenure burned bright, even if it was relatively short. Acquired before the 1980 season, he immediately became a dominant late-inning force. He was not just effective, he was overpowering. Holland attacked hitters with a heavy fastball and a sharp breaking pitch, and when he was locked in, games felt over by the eighth inning. During that 1980 championship season, he was a major reason the Phillies could shorten games and protect leads on their way to a World Series title.

What stood out most about Holland was his ability to miss bats. He did not rely on contact or defensive help. He simply blew hitters away. That made him an ideal closer in an era when the role was still evolving. At his peak, he was one of the best relievers in baseball, not just on the Phillies roster.

The downside was durability and consistency over time. Holland’s workload and arm issues began to take a toll, and his performance dipped after that peak. By the early 1980s, he was still useful, but he was no longer quite the same dominant force. That context matters, because the Phillies were not trading the 1980 version of Holland. They were trading a pitcher who had already started to slide from that elite level.

Kent Tekulve in Philadelphia

Tekulve could not have been more different. Where Holland overpowered hitters, Tekulve baffled them. With his submarine delivery, Tekulve created uncomfortable at-bats and weak contact. He was not going to rack up strikeouts the way Holland did, but he excelled at inducing groundballs and disrupting timing.

By the time he arrived in Philadelphia, Tekulve was already a proven reliever from his long run in Pittsburgh. What the Phillies got was reliability. He took the ball often, handled heavy workloads, and rarely put himself in trouble. His control was sharp, and his approach fit well in high-leverage spots even if it looked unconventional.

Tekulve’s value to the Phillies was not about replacing Holland’s peak dominance. It was about stabilizing the bullpen. He became a trusted option who could pitch in multiple situations, not just the ninth inning. That flexibility mattered as the team transitioned from its 1980 core into a slightly different roster construction.

Comparing styles and impact

The contrast between the two pitchers is almost textbook. Holland represented power and intimidation. Tekulve represented deception and efficiency. One overwhelmed hitters, the other outsmarted them.

In terms of peak performance, Holland likely had the higher ceiling. His best season in Philadelphia was simply more dominant than anything Tekulve produced after the trade. If you are choosing one pitcher to close out a must-win game at his absolute best, Holland makes a strong case.

But baseball is not played in snapshots. Over a longer stretch, Tekulve’s consistency and durability gave the Phillies something they needed at that moment. He was available, dependable, and adaptable. While he may not have matched Holland’s flash, he provided steadiness.

Evaluating the trade

From Philadelphia’s perspective, this was less about winning a headline deal and more about managing risk and roster needs. They moved a declining asset in Holland and received a pitcher who could still contribute at a reliable level. Frankie Griffin, while part of the trade, was not the centerpiece.

For Pittsburgh, the trade was a gamble on upside. If Holland rediscovered his earlier form, they would gain a high-impact reliever. For Philadelphia, the goal was more practical. They wanted innings they could trust.

In that sense, the deal feels balanced when viewed through the proper lens. The Phillies did not replace Holland’s peak, but they were not really trying to. They traded volatility for dependability, and Tekulve delivered exactly that.

Looking back, it is the kind of trade that reflects two teams at different points. The Phillies were adjusting and looking for stability. The Pirates were willing to take a chance. Neither side made a catastrophic mistake, and both got something that fit their situation at the time.

Philadelphia Baseball Events for April 20

  • April 20, 1903 – On Opening Day, before 8,376 fans at Huntington Avenue Baseball Grounds, the Boston Americans defeat the Philadelphia Athletics in the morning game of a Patriots’ Day twin bill, 9 – 4. Connie Mack‘s Athletics win the matinee match-up featuring two future Hall of Fame pitchers, 10 – 7, as 27,658 spectators enjoy watching starters Eddie Plank and Cy Young oppose one another.
  • April 20, 1920 – Manager Gavvy Cravath inserted himself as a pinch-hitter and hits a three-run homer to beat the New York Giants 3-0. It was his 119th and final major-league home run, a major-league record that was broken by Babe Ruth the following season.
  • April 20, 1932 – The New York Yankees draw the largest paid attendance, 55,452, for any Yankee Stadium opener. Babe Ruth homers as Lefty Gomez beats Lefty Grove in the 8 – 3 victory over the Philadelphia Athletics.
  • April 20, 1949 – Willie “Puddinhead” Jones hits four straight doubles, tying a major league record. The Phils lose to Boston 6-5.
  • April 20, 1984 – Steve Carlton gives up a home run to opposing pitcher Tim Leary — Leary’s only career home run. The Mets win 3-1.
  • April 20, 1985 – With John Denny on the mound, Juan Samuel records 12 assists at second base in a 7-6 victory over the Mets.
  • April 20, 1995 – Signed free agent Gary Varsho, who would go on to manage in the Phillies minor league system. He is also the father of Daulton Varsho, who was named after teammate Darren Daulton, of the Toronto Blue Jays.
  • April 20, 2001 – With two out in the bottom of the 7th against the Braves, Kevin Jordan hits a pinch-hit grand slam to lead the Phillies to an 8-3 win.
  • April 20, 2021 – Coming in with a 15 inning scoreless streak, Connor Brogdon gives up two 3-run home runs in the same inning in a 10-7 loss to San Francisco.

ICYMI

GO DEEPER INTO THE PHILLIES WITH BONUS COVERAGE ON PBN EXTRA INNINGS.

Sign up for a free subscription and get our weekly newsletter delivered to your inbox. Or, sign up for a paid subscription ($5 per month/$45 per year) and get deeper coverage of the Phillies and the Minor League affiliates. And it all comes with a 7-Day Free Trial.

Philadelphia Baseball Birthdays for April 20

  • Dave Bancroft (born 1891) – Started his career with the Phillies in 1915 and spent five-plus seasons with them until he was traded to the New York Giants in July, 1920. Inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame by the Veterans Stadium in 1971.
  • Tommy Hutton (born 1946) – Played six seasons (1972-1977) with the Phillies and hit .253/.350/.349/.699 in 655 games.

Please scroll down to comment on this story or to give it a rating. We appreciate your feedback!

PBN Logo

Disclaimer: Some of the products featured or linked on this website may generate income for Philly Baseball News through affiliate commissions, sponsorships, or direct sales. We only promote items we believe in, but please assume that PBN may earn a cut from qualifying purchases that you make using a link on this site.

Privacy Policy | Contact us

© 2026 LV Sports Media. All rights reserved.