Somewhere in the offices of Major League Baseball, someone has a pretty cool job. Likely, this person is stuck away in some shadowy office in a back hallway, but it’s still a neat gig; they probably make a decent living, too. Their job is to come up with ideas on how his bosses can change America’s Pastime. They analyze every part of baseball and come up with solutions without a problem.

This person talked his bosses into an experiment that took place during the Arizona Fall League (AFL) season. The premise was to increase offense in the league by making outfielders play in a specific spot in the field no matter what the beloved analytics say about where they should be playing.

By the way, isn’t it interesting that teams invest more and more money into analytics and MLB looks for ways to beat analytics and limit their influence in the game?

Salt River Fields – the proving ground

Salt River Fields in Scottsdale, Arizona is an interesting ballpark. It is home to the Salt River Rafters of the AFL and is also the Spring Training home of both the Colorado Rockies and the Arizona Diamondbacks. Technologically, it is the closest thing you will find to a Major League Baseball stadium. It is fully outfitted with all of the latest gadgetry to measure every step a player takes.

With that technology in place, MLB used the ballpark to experiment with where outfielders can play in an effort to improve offense in baseball. The rule package put in place by MLB in 2023 did do part of what it was intended to do; it cut game times by approximately 25 minutes and also upped the number and success rate of stolen bases. The new rules – the pitch clock, bigger bases, limiting pitcher disengagements, and limiting infield shifts – failed to increase the overall offense in baseball though, which is something MLB really wants.

Again, just like the battle with analytics, isn’t it odd that MLB fails to realize that if they increase the offense, game times are going to go up again?

This experiment requires outfielders to basically play “straight up.” A video board behind home plate shows if each outfielder is in the correct position. If their position is marked with a white “O” on a green background, they’re in the “legal” area. If it is red with an “X” then they have to move into the area. If it’s yellow with a dash, then you are close to going out of the designated area.

The area was determined using the hawk-eye system that is the key component for the ABS system and replay review. The grounds crew placed subtle dark green hashmarks on the field at the designated spot to let fielders know that is the center of the allowed zone. About three steps in any direction would move that player out of the position that he is allowed to be in.

The penalty for an outfielder being “out of position” was only enforced if the ball was hit to that player. In that case, the umpire places the batter and any baserunners on base at their discretion.

Because Salt River Fields is the only AFL park outfitted with everything needed for the experiment, only games played there required players to position themselves in the required position.

The Results of the Outfield Positioning Experiment

Because the designated area is shallower than most players would position themselves, outfielders have to move back to make plays more often than they normally would. It also keeps the gaps open by eliminating, or at least strictly restricting, shifting by outfielders. For corner outfielders, not only are they playing shallower than they would in a lot of situations they are also playing closer to the foul line than they would. In other words, the positioning rewards hard-hit balls and flyballs down the line, and takes away some of the bloop singles.

As expected, the experiment resulted in a sharp increase in runs, doubles, and triples. In games at Salt River Field, runs were 34-percent higher than they were in other AFL venues. Games averaged 15.9 runs per game at Salt River. Doubles were up 81-percent to nearly five per game.

The biggest increase was in triples. Triples at Salt River Fields were up 236-percent over other venues in the AFL. Games averaged 2.2 triples and in one single game there were an AFL record five triples.

Don’t worry, it’s not going to be a rule anytime soon

This experiment is in its infancy, at best. There are a lot of things to overcome. First, how would different ballpark dimensions come into play? There is the fact that like the infield shift, the rule would fly in the face of the analytics of the game that teams are beholden to.

While the experiment yielded the desired results, that little person in the back office will need to put together charts and graphs showing why and how this would all work. Then, his bosses would have to take this to owners and players. Right now, those folks have enough on their plate to deal with.

For those and many other reasons, don’t expect outfield positioning to be regulated any time soon. Just know that it’s out there and could become a thing at some point down the road when all of the labor unrest is settled.

What are your thoughts on the outfield positioning experiment? Leave your comment below.


Please scroll down to comment!

We appreciate your feedback!

Banner for Philly Baseball News featuring logo, slogan, and skyline of Philadelphia with social media icons.

Disclaimer: Some of the products featured or linked on this website may generate income for Philly Baseball News through affiliate commissions, sponsorships, or direct sales. We only promote items we believe in, but please assume that PBN may earn a cut from qualifying purchases that you make using a link on this site.

Privacy Policy | Contact us

© 2026 LV Sports Media. All rights reserved.